As much quality that The Dark Knight has, I would say it's not much of a super hero movie and mostly a crime drama wrapped in sleek Batman packaging. And as much as I was riveted when I watched it in theaters, I haven't seen it since.
I'll take the Tim Burton Batman films (which I've seen numerous times and owned in multiple media). Also, I'm a big fan of Superman movies, even though I know despite having a bias for Superman above all other super heroes, the quality doesn't compare to Batman films.
That said, the best mix of quality movie making, "rewatchability", and super hero spirit belongs to The Incredibles.







