| Fei-Hung said: And you are speaking to an interfaith and cohesion expert who has given evidence and worked for leading organisations in the country. Every link you have posted isn't from a reliable scholar and merely points to small sections taken out of context without much understanding of hadith or quran. Reliable scholars like Habib Ali Jifri, Hamza Yusuf, leading scholars throughout the UK which represent the majority of the Muslims disagree. Just like any faith, any topic, you will always have people who will take things and spin them out of context for their own agenda.in fact your links have proven the point I made earlier where the extremists on either side have the same twisted view and believes in the faith whilst the majority disagree and end up having to fend themselves from both ends. |
Well, I am not surprised at the Appeal to Authority fallacy. You need to prove to me that TheMaskedArab took the small sections out of context. You need to prove that his citations aren't reliable, especially when the verses he has quoted are "Sahih" (authentic) and provided the proper context. He also cited proper scholars and provided the specific quotes necessary to back his arguments.
The last paragraph actually applies strongly to you. You, yourself, are an extremist because you refuse to acknowledge facts when they are presented to you. This is rather apparent when you continuously resort to fallacies, most notably the Appeal to Authority instead of telling me what particular passages TheMaskedArab interpreted or cited incorrectly.
So let me ask you, what particular parts of the video did TheMaskedArab take passages out of context? What is the proper context for the passages and provide me the full verses. How do you know the scholars he has cited are not reliable? What about these scholars make them not trustworthy?
