TheBlackNaruto said:
MTZehvor said:
Here's perhaps a clearer example of what defines a hack and slash, between games technically in the same franchise.
Take the Legend of Zelda and its spin off, Hyrule Warriors. Mainline Legend of Zelda games do not focus around hack and slash combat. There's no emphasis on combos, minimal variety in melee attacks, switching weapons isn't seamless, and Link generally doesn't move very fast. None of these are inherently bad things; and Zelda's combat fits a game tending more towards exploration like it is.
With that said, take Hyrule Warriors. There's a heavy emphasis on combos, a number of different attack strings you can pull off (though it's a lot less than something like DMC or Bayonetta), and characters move extremely quickly. There's a sense of flashiness to the combat that mainline Zelda titles don't focus on.
That's what really makes a hack and slash game, a hack and slash game. So far, from what we've seen (and admittedly, this could very well change if the E3 demo is unrepresentative of the finished product), God of War 4 doesn't fall into the latter category. Kratos seems pretty slow with the exception of his dodge move, and combat is far less about variety and combos and more about simply running up and mashing the attack button. |
I agree with everything outside of this. We can't really say combat is far less about variety seeing as we don't know what will all be implemented. Heck it is clear there will be bow gameplay, magic as well considering what he did with his Ax looking like frost, hand to hand combat with no weapon as well. That's 3 different things right there in this short demo. So we can't really make your last conclusion to be honest.
|
Hence the "if the E3 demo is representative of the final product." In essence, if the E3 demo is basically what the core combat will look like, then I think my statement holds without too much room for debate. If there's magic that can be switched to on the fly, or the bow can be used in the middle of attacks to extend strings, then yeah, it's worth reconsidering. But none of that was shown in the demo.
