By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

lol it's already been said but Majora's Mask definitely fits that game that's cheery on the surface but so creepy otherwise.

This really doesn't fit too well, but I remember an experience from Warcraft. There was this troll woman in Outlands who seemed to run a nursery or something, she had all these babies around her out in the middle of nowhere. Later in Warlords you find out she's there in the past, but she's not a troll (forget what she was) and instead learn she's been stealing the lives of others to continue living indefinitely. Really made that seemingly sweet nursery from years later really look like something else entirely lol

ummm... Earthbound has plenty of that atmosphere. I'm not coming up with as many examples as I thought I would.