(Updated now with poll) E3: Zelda Breath of the Wild Vs Horizon Zero Dawn = which one has the "wow factor"?

[DivinePaladin]

TheBlackNaruto said:

DivinePaladin said:
This thread is literally asking for console warfare.

I personally don't get much out of Horizon. I'm hoping they escalate the gameplay, or the plot, or something, because right now there isn't much in it for me.

Zelda looks excellent but is still got some clear issues left to fix, and I can only hope the NX version looks better because while the game is gorgeous, it's clearly pushing the Wii U's limits.

But to answer the question: Who cares? They're not really comparable games and it's going to come down to a simple Sony v Nintendo argument almost every time if you try to compare them.

Actually no it will not come down to that almost every time you compare them it will come down to which game you prefer plain and simple. People can have discusiions about these two games if they chose what's wrong with that? This thread is asking a question not asking for console warfare. And it was a good question to big games from Sony and Nin both seem open world and like really good games. So what's wrong with asking questions?

If you read through the thread a lot of people have given some great break downs of why the think which did what so it is a good discussion.

Half of the arguments have come down to "what do you see in [opposing game]? It's just a generic [company] game." If you see a clearer discussion developing here then by all means continue it, and try to focus it that way, but it's been needless Zelda or Horizon bashing/riding all thread with very little middle ground. I have my doubts about both because they both look to have put style over substance, but a thread directly comparing the two isn't the best place to air concerns. It'll just get drowned out.