When is murder justified by self-defense?

[vivster]

Teeqoz said:

vivster said:

We already have laws in place to decide what is extreme and what not. It's called "life long" sentence. I see no reason to keep those people alive when they're proven to be extremely harmful to other people.

 

I realize that my "extreme" opinion requires a flawless judicial system as to not kill off innocent bystanders. Well, no system that depends on human decisions is perfect.

You've went from "If a person wants to willingly physically harm another person it always deserves death." to "We already have laws in place to decide what is extreme and what not. It's called "life long" sentence. I see no reason to keep those people alive when they're proven to be extremely harmful to other people."

First one = extreme

Second one =/= extreme

So which is it?

I'm only talking about violent crimes. Every violent crime that deserves a life long imprisonment, deserves death. Of course there are more crimes that deserve death but they are harder to quantify. Would need new laws.

In a perfect world all people that willingly and seriously harm their fellow humans should be greated by instant death. They have nothing to give society and only take away from it.