I think the Xbox360 list is smarter. The FPS crowd has already been tapped out mostly and more of the big games are RPG and ACTION type games.
If I was going to bet, I would say that the Xbox360 list will make more of an impact in terms of sales than the PS3 list simply because they have the most variety in their big games. Socom, Resistance, MGS4 are all hardcore shooter games whereas Fable 2, Too Human, Left 4 dead are more accessible for new players.
In terms of system sellers I would pick the Xbox360 because they have changed tack and aquired some awesome RPG games and action games this year.
In terms of critical acclaim? I think the PS3 lineup will edge the Xbox360.
In terms of total sales? I think the Xbox360 lineup will beat out the PS3 one yet again by a good margin due to the wide range of tastes it caters for.
Tease.
