By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Teeqoz said:

Ganoncrotch said:

 Mensa’s test includes questions like, “2D is to mobius strip as 3D is to ______.” Google says the answer is “Klein bottle.”

 

I actually knew the answer to that haha. And also, Mensa can eat shit, because true Klein bottles can only exist in 4D.

When's the last time you tried embedding a Möbius strip in two-dimensional (Euclidean) space?  True Möbius strips can only exist in 3D, or higher.

It is a terrible, terrible question relying on popular misconceptions, but it's not terrible for the reason you claim.  The Klein bottle has the same dimension as the Möbius strip: they're both two-dimensional surfaces, so the analogy is very poor.  One of them has a boundary (an exposed edge), while the other is closed.  One can be realized in R^3 while the other can only be immersed in R^3 and embedded in R^4.  That doesn't imbue the Klein bottle with higher dimensionality.

A better answer might have been the solid Klein bottle, which is a 3-dimensional manifold with boundary, just as the Möbius strip is a 2-dimensional manifold with boundary.  But that is a distinct object — it's as different from a Klein bottle as the Möbius strip is different from a circle (1-sphere).