Alright, We Need To Talk About Quantum Break

[mornelithe]

The_BlackHeart__ said:

Here is a list of the top 10 games released in April according to their Meta Score

Dark Souls 3 - 90
Hitman Episode 2 - 87
Dirt Rally - 86
Ratchet & Clank - 86
Tales from Borderlands - 85
Letter Quest - 84
Enter the Gungeon - 84
Severed - 83
The Banner Saga 2 - 83
1979 Revolution - 82

The mandatory 3 honorary mentions go to:

Bravely Second -  81
Battlefleet Gothic - 79
Alienation - 79

I don't understand people saying that Quantum Break has GOTY potential. It's not even a top 10 in the month it released.

Could we just simply call things the way they are? Quantum Break was a cool experiment, but not a very good game.

Because Metacritic is hot garbage, for a variety of reasons.  If you're not aware of it's flaws, there are plenty of threads that've talked about it in the past.   Read what they're writing, not just seeing random key words.  Also, read some of the reviews that metacritic uses, especially the lower and higher ones, to get a sense of what the reviewer is actually judging.

Also, notice these are peoples personal GOTY, up to this point.  They're not saying it will, they're simply saying it's their current choice.