Seeing this image, do you think Sony and Microsoft kept their promises?

[binary solo]

Mike_L said:

binary solo said:
What are those images exactly? They are so similar that surely they were not compiled by Sony and MS. They must be compiled by someone else based on various PR and advertising that had been around at the time.

Bold: Wouldn't that still be Sony and Microsoft's promises?

I think you're right though. I think someone made the Sony list as a response to Microsoft's. I'm pretty sure Microsoft's list is official. I'm almost certain I saw that picture a few years ago posted here by someone who got it in a mail from Microsoft. Anyone able to confirm?

Well, yeah, but unless the information is sourced back to an official ad or PR statement it's largely unsubstantiated. If the MS image is official PR then you can assess it directly. And if the Sony one is something some random Sony fan pulled together then some of the "claims" are merely mirroring the MS claims. For instance "Biggest Blockbuster Exclusives" is the random fan's claim, not Sony's claim. So you can't "check off" Sony on that claim since they [possibly] never made it.