psychicscubadiver on 22 February 2016
-Who is more evil?
Carnage
-Who is scarier?
Carnage
-Who is more dangerous?
Carnage
-Who is the better villain overall?
The Joker
The first three don't necessarily add up to the last one. Carnage is a thing, a force, a terrifying presence, but the Joker has a personality beyond 'kill everyone'. A great villain needs to engage the audience at some level not just be killing machine.
Though, I'd pick many other villains over the Joker as 'better villains'. He is far overrated in my opinion, helped by his 'Joker Immunity'. Any reasonable justice system would have put him down long ago, for or against capital punishment be damned.
