Some of the games I got this year I really liked:
Bloodborne, Until Dawn, Driveclub.
It caught a lot of flack - but I also enjoyed The Order 1886. Maybe not worth the full $60 price - but I think it's on sale now for $20.
Some really great indies were Rocket League, Everybody's Gone To The Rapture , Vanishing Of Ethan Carter.
Also - if you didn't play them last gen - the remastered Last Of Us, God Of War 3 and Uncharted Collection were all superb.