Highest on Metacritic vs. Game with most GOTY awards

[Alkibiádēs]

ClassicGamingWizzz said:

Alkibiádēs said:

Then why do so many people prefer Minecraft over TLOU? Then why are there so many Minecraft clones yet no one copied TLOU? Why didn't it sell more on PS3? I mean Super Mario Galaxy sold double of what TLOU sold. I mean if it was hands down the best game of last gen then why didn't it perform better or have a bigger impact on the gaming industry?

Ok you are right, candy crush is the best game of last gen, millions and millions played it so it most be the most fucking amazing game out there.

It's a mobile game and thus doesn't belong to console generations, so yeah, you're wrong. It's also comparing a free game to games that are $30-$70. When it comes to mobile games though, yes, Candy Crush is a good game. It wouldn't be played by millions of people otherwise. You just said TLOU was hands down the best game of last gen, as in "there's no discussion possible, it's a fact". I beg to disagree and gave you reasons why other games can claim to be the game of the generation. Minecraft outperforms TLOU on pretty much any parameter I can think of: sales, cultural impact, influence in the game industry, longevity/legacy, merchandise, spin-offs, innovation, etc.