Highest on Metacritic vs. Game with most GOTY awards

[Alkibiádēs]

pokoko said:

Alkibiádēs said:

pokoko said:
Discussions like this always end up entertaining. There are always justifications people make up about why their own favorite didn't win as many GOTY awards or they call those that won more awards "overrated". It's like a Butthurt Festival.

All because a relatively tiny group of people collectively liked one game a bit more than any other game.

Ah, the classic "I'm above everyone else, look how cool I am post". You're pretty much saying nothing can ever be over- or underrated. And I'm pretty sure it's against the rules to call members of this site butthurt.

"Overrated" is often a justification for people who are pouting over the fact that something they like got overshadowed.  This is especially true when that "overrated" game is acclaimed both critically and commercially.  Calling it overrated is like saying, "well, they didn't really enjoy it all that much, they just thought they did."  That's generally nonsense.  When someone really pounds on the "overrated" button, there is often some sense of insecurity involved.

There are a lot of games I don't like.  Do I mount a soapbox and proclaim them overrated?  No, I just consider them "games I don't like very much."  For instance, there are people who like jumping simulators, which bore me to sleep, especially when the characters are cardboard cutouts that generate the emotional attachment of a wet twinkie.  However, it doesn't bother me in the slightest that other people like these games.  People are different, therefore what they like is often different.

But, hey, feel free to tell us about how these different games that you don't like are overrated and how the games you do like should win more GOTY awards.  I'm sure there are many people who find that to be a mature response.

Do you even know what simple terms like under- and overrated mean? If TLOU wasn't critically acclaimed or commercially succesful I couldn't call it overated. A game can be good and still be overrated, take Ocarina of Time for example. It seems you're the only one who's insecure here if you can't accept the opinion of someone who thinks a game you like is overrated (which ironically proves, imo, that TLOU is overrated). I've seen plenty of ND fans call games like Tomb Raider shit on the internet even though they'd praise the exact same game if it was made by their lord and saviour. No wonder I think ND is overrated.

All I'm saying is that TLOU belongs in the "I am Legends quality category" and not the "nobel prize for literature quality category" as some people on the internet would have you believe. The fact that every GOTY winner on that list is a serious "mature" game is quite telling. No, it's not very mature to only like "mature" stuff and being ashamed of liking "childish" things. These GOTY awards pretend to speak for the entire gaming community while they only speak for a small group of people who probably take themselves too seriously.