I have had all 3 for a while. As a platform as the PS4 has more games and new players have Bloodborne to go back and play.
X1 is a close secind though. Halo 5, Gears Ultimate, RotTR (if you can't wait a year on PS4), Rare Replay, and Forza 5 is the better holiday lineup. However on the PS4 side Until Dawn, Dragon Quest Heros, Tales of Zesteria, and the Unchartes collection, Disgaea 5, and Sword Art Online Lost song is pretty good too.
Now had the PS4 not also have games released throughout the year (MS dropped the ball here) my opinion would still be a close one, except X1 would have the edge. As it is though, the PS4 just has more to offer on the gaming front.








