Highest on Metacritic vs. Game with most GOTY awards

[Alkibiádēs]

peterdavid12345 said:

Alkibiádēs said:

Naughty Dog is immensely overrated. I see reviewers complaining all the time about sequels that don't change up enough, but the very same people will no doubt vote for Uncharted 4 as GOTY next year. Uncharted's story is about the same quality as Indiana Jones, yet reviewers praise it like it's Tolstoy's War and Peace or Dante Alighieri's La Divina Commedia.

The same with The Last of Us, the story is on par with I am Legend (a movie I like, but hardly think is a generation defining movie...).

o_O ???

Well, that's like your opinion man, lol. I guess one's man treasure is another man's trash, is very true :3.

Anyways, your opinion is wrong tbh. What about the Metacritics User's Score ? I mean if the game is surely overrated, im sure gamers will downgraded like they do to other games to balancing things out.

Not with the Last of Us tho, it's still the most rated and one of the best rated game on Metacritics.

 

If it had a low meta/userscore it wouldn't be overrated. Besides, metacritic is pointless. I've always found that Naughty Dog makes Hollywood rip-offs, they haven't done an original thing in years (narrative and gameplay wise). Aren't PS fans always bitching about how useless userscores are anyway? And I fail to see how my opinion about something as subjective as taste can be wrong, but eh, whatever rows your boat. The Last of Us has some of the worst immersion breaking enemy/ally AI I've ever witnessed in a modern game (not counting shovelware/trash). And that's bad in a game that tries to be realistic. It takes you out of the experience. For the same reason I can't take Uncharted serious, Nathan Drake would be the biggest serial killer/mass murderer in the world if any of it was true. I don't have that problem with, for example, Mario taking out harmless looking enemies like koopas because Mario is supposed to make no sense and be silly.

My game of the year this year is Super Mario Maker (especially after the free updates), but we all know a kiddy 2D platformer can't win such awards.