Ranking Star Wars: Where is VII?

[Cruzer]

Soundwave said:

Cruzer said:

 

I have to disagree here. It is better quality wise and as a product of course, vut as a Star Wars movie it does not compare. The opening and closing sequence s in Phantom Menace are better than any part of TFA, including the "forced" scene of someone's obvious death. TPM also had better adventure, which TFA failed at.

 

What adventure? lol. 

Episode I is about a freaking TAX TRADE DISPUTE. 

Episode VII is about the search for the great Jedi in the galaxy, the mythic Luke Skywalker. 

TFA is going to crush all the prequels in box office, the general public is voting with their wallets. Prequels had no believable human characters aside from maybe Palpatine, and even he I thought went too hammy/silly with the role by the end of ROTS. 

TFA brings back the feel of the OT, that's why it's crushing every box office record that stands in its way. CGI effects do not make up for human characters, Lucas lost the plot with the prequels from the get go. He was more interested in making Jar-Jar work than anyone else. 

 

Episode I had plenty of adventure and had many subplots tied into the main story. Specifically Obi, his master and Anakin all brought the adventure and the movie had more mystery to keep me interested as opposed to how predictable and unoriginal TFA was. My brother who seen the original movies in theater agreed about how predictable the movie was.

TFA is about running from the First Order and getting captured a bilkion times, but nice try lol. As if Episode 4 did nit already use that plot anyway.

TFA just copies the original s but lacks the soul. Box office success has nothing to do with quality and eith Disney owning the franchise now o f course their name would make an already popular franchise bigger lol.

The removal of the force history will also make these new SW movies more mainstream. Everything else you said is ridiculous so I won't address it.