S.Peelman on 25 December 2015
Yeah, all of them are good, well, almost, but anyway:
2003: agree with GotY
2004: -
2005: -
2006: with Metacritic
2007: Metacritic
2008: GotY
2009: -
2010: Metacritic
2011: Metacritic
2012: uhh... Neither 
2013: same... but I'll take GotY's
2014: Metacritic
2015: also not really a choice I'd go for
