So Xenoblade X has an 84 on metacritix because there is too much to do and the world is too big?

[DonFerrari]

Nautilus said:

DonFerrari said:

if a book after readingf for 2h haven't enticed you the least would you obligue yourself to read another 100?

You may say it's unfair, unprofessional but it's his true opinion that the book don't deserve to be read

Of course he is obliged!Its his job to read the whole book to make a fair and good review.he is being paid for it, to do that single job.What are you saying is like if a teacher had a student with difficulty learning something, the teacher should just give up on him?He may in the end fail(the student), but its teachers job to try its best to make the student understand.I was a bit extreme in my example, but I think you got the idea.He can say all he want about the book being bad, but he needs to experience it all to truly say its bad.If you cant handle it, well then, you are in the wrong job(the reviewers in case of course)

He is paid to review the book, not to read all.

Do restaurant critics eat the whole menu to evaluate or ask for their "full course" annd the restaurante chef decides what to serve? If he serves his worst that is his fault alone.