Picko on 10 May 2008
I'd have a 100 point scale that is normally distributed with a mean of 50. I'd have two reviewers review the game, one who is a fan of the genre and one that is largely indifferent or isn't a fan. That would help with balancing the bias that reviewers are often accused of having.
I would finally have a "Better than/Worse than" category for easy comparisons between similar games.
Debating with fanboys, its not
all that dissimilar to banging ones
head against a wall
