Amazon US November monthly bestsellers and general Amazon-based discussion.

[binary solo]

the-pi-guy said:

Bryank75 said:

It is strange, they seem to be contradicting themselves. Saying PS4 was best seller on BF and then saying the Gears bundle was best selling bundle.....

Just because:

A>B>C>D>E>F

Doesn't mean that (below) can't be true.  

B+C+D> A+E+F

 

">They specifically say "the top pick", not "our top pick."

 

 

Indeed. On closer inspection there are many possible ways to interpret this. It could be that the Gears bundle is the #1 selling console sku nation-wide. It could also be that the Gears bundle was only the number 1 console sku at Target, and Infoscout has not actually announced a nation-wide winner yet. They announced previously that PS4 was number 1 by revenue at Best Buy. So they could be being retailer specific here too. They could also be saying that the best deal antion-wide was the Target Gears bundle deal, which basically got you a Xb one and Gears of War Ultimate for $239, and they may not be saying anything about which console or bundle sold best anywhere.

So there is too much ambiguity in what INfoscout has said to really come to any firm conclusion. We need more PR.