| ctk495 said: So how much will you give brawl? |
You know the answer to that. If you don't I shall take up collections in the Brawl thread for a 10 lb. Tuna fish. ^_^
@Kasz
I don't really like point scores. When I read a written review, I'm looking for fun aspects of the game and less fun aspects. When it comes down to a star/number, I'm looking for an answer to the question "Is this game worth my time?" The more numbers you put out, the harder it is to get that answer. I don't know how big the difference between an 82 and an 84 is. I don't even think any reviewer out there could qualify that.
In reality, I could probably only go with 4 stars: Avoid, Rent then Not Buy, Rent then Maybe Buy, and Buy. The 5th is there to round it off and to mark the truly exceptional games.
@Desroko
For the most part, I don't believe in half anythings. A game is either worth buying or it's not. A game is either worth renting or it's not. The only wishy-washy part is whether a game is worth buying after a rental and that's pure individual preference in my rating system.
@dtwei
The problem with that is that there are a lot of games that would be fun to play but not something I'd want to own or ever really play again. Zack & Wiki falls into that category for me. Playing through it once is a lot of fun, but not necessarily something I'd want to do over and over.
