P vs Z
Splatoon is just too limited as a game. Still no voice chat (big for some people), limited choices (maps) in online play, and a horrendous local co-op. It's not bad, but it's not that great either. Likewise, it's not really that special as an fps. It's a colorful team based shooter, like team fortress, with increased customizability, like destiny, and increased movement options, like Titanfall. It didn't revolutionize an industry that was never generic to begin with.
P vs Z is also not the greatest game out there, but I do think the larger maps and voice chat gives it the edge







