Metal gear solid might have good writing, but the fact that there is so much damn exposition drives me crazy. Other than the original PS1 MSG (still the best in the series), I can never finish the games. I get sick of watching those long cut scenes. If MGS was a Hollywood movie, it would be like The Lady in the Water with guns.
And Super Paper Mario had clever writing, but do you really need 10,000 voice bubbles to get a plot point across.
I vote for Eternal Darkness, especially when you play it multiple times. You pick up things in the story you missed the first time through.








