Amazon US October monthly bestsellers and general Amazon based discussion

[jlmurph2]

GribbleGrunger said:

jlmurph2 said:

False. Week 1 it was #38. Stop trying to downplay the fact that a console that is releasing this month is actually selling.

Seriously, just stop this fanboy nonsense. I'm not trying to 'downplay' anything, I'm simply trying to understand something we've been following all month and you have only found interest in since the Halo bundle took the lead.

Nah I was actually here before that happened. You were the one keeping track of the hourlies. You of all people should know that Halo was passed the 50 mark during the first week of counting October sales (October 5-11) which arent as far back as you think. What exactly made you come to this "pre-orders from past months added" theory?