Alaska Renames Columbus Day ‘Indigenous Peoples Day’!

[Nautilus]

Teeqoz said:

Nautilus said:

Well, if it werent for him, we wouldnt have the countrys, and its cultures, that we have today, or at least the countrys wouldnt be the same, so its not only bad things that he has done.But I understand what you mean.

The problem is, if we apply that though to all holidays or prizes names we have, we would need to change many of their names.An easy example would be the Noble prizes.The guy that came up with the idea to award prizes to excepcional people, and that includes peace prizes, was the same guy that build bombs and armaments for living.He only came up with the idea of awards because he didnt want to be remember as a man who build weapons that killed people.Should we then rename the Nobel prize because of that?I agree that we shoudlnt forget the horrible things that Colombo did, but also completely ignore his achievements, even if the means are completely wrong, is not right

There's a difference though. Alfred Nobel's research resulted in horrible things, yes, but that wasn't his intention. He was a good man. Chirstoffer Columbus on the other hand...

I am not saying we should completely ignore his achievements, but that doesn't mean we have to celebrate Columbus Day.

But its already part of our culture.And he had a different perspective and moral than we have now.We are, after all, talking about a difference of 500 years.Good people in that age though that black people were animals, because their religion said to them that they had no soul, and so killing them wasnt wrong.And people believed it because they thought it was right, that what their religion said was right.It was ignorance in most cases, not real evil.It isnt completely fair to judge them by our standards, when they had a completely different view about the world.We actually have a better society today because of them, because of their mistakes, and we learned about them.

Well, i think in the end it really depends on people, if they want to give more importance to the good side of Colombo or its bad side, but in the end for me renaming it(the day) is just foolish.Most people just celebrate the day and its meaning, not the person, and renaming it would just cause more harm than good.(confusing people and all)