Which Sells More Uncharted or ROTR - Update: Decision - Uncharted

[DivinePaladin]

Aerys said:

DivinePaladin said:

A year old port of a PS3 game sold 3 million not counting the digital sales (which have been bundled for nearly a year since). A trilogy port on what is now a bigger install base, which will be bundled for at least six months and likely a full year one one of the top three fastest selling consoles of all time, will very likely outsell almost every exclusive release Microsoft has except for probably Halo 5. Once TR hits PS4 that could very possibly shift over to TR winning, but again, TLoUR sold more physically than TR did on 360 and XBO combined. It's not a stretch to think that with nearly twice the install base and bundling until the end of time that Drake's gonna win this one at LEAST until the PS4 port. 

You forget one thing : Uncharted 4, Uncharted Colleciton sales will drop a lot because of that, people will forget the collection, while TR will continue to sell being a false exclusive until PS4 version release

People are going to suddenly forget the first three games that many didn't play the moment the fourth comes out, even though the game will be bundled well past that point? Naughty Dog is the one first party company that Sony consistently bundles, and they're almost Nintendo tier when they do. 

 

The impact that TR PS4 is gonna have may not even be as big as you'd expect because, to counter your Uncharted 4 kills NDC argument, a year is a long time for a game to not come out on competing platforms. There's a good chance the game does below expectations on PS4 because of this. Not to mention the PS4 sales may be irrelevant since this thread was initially meant to be XB vs PS sales. If we're comparing a multiplat over two gens vs an exclusive on one, the results are probably predictable, not to mention irrelevant.