By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
padib said:
JWeinCom said:
padib said:

Let me ask you a question. Do you think that stealing is wrong?

Just to save you both time, stealing is in direct conflict with a person's right to own property, which is agreed upon almost universally as a basic human right.  It is not an apt comparison.

Since when does everything revolve around basic human rights as defined by some magical unicorn somewhere in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean?

It absolutely does not.  The reasoning behind the right to property is fairly well explained by many moral philosophers, most notably in the western world John Locke.

I don't know if you actually want to go through the pointlessly assinine exercise of debating whether or not stealing is wrong, but it is objectively healthier for a society to protect property rights.  We can come to this conclusion through basic human empathy (I don't like my things being taken from me, you are a human being like me, therefore I should not take your things), and we can easily see how stealing removes incentives for hard work, and leads to violence, etc.  It is pretty easy to see, even in a simple microcosm like a Kindergarten classroom, how stealing leads to conflict and disruption.  We have good reason to believe the consequences of stealing are detrimental to society.

I'm really hoping you're not going to actually argue that we should allow stealing...