How not to fall into the "Walking Simulator" trap (Jimquisition)

[pokoko]

Goodnightmoon said:

pokoko said:
Beloved Jim Sterling? The guy who gave Deadly Premonition a 10 is going to tell us what video-games should be like?

Nah.

I prefer the system of letting people make what they want. That way, all sorts of tastes can be represented and I can play what I like.

That review was a joke:

 "This game is so bad, it's not just become good. It's pretty close to perfect." 

It´s called humor, english people have it, you know?

And even if it wasn´t a joke, a bad review in 5 or 6 years is not a reason to discredit someone. 

It's ... not a joke.  It's the official review and he loved the game.  Try reading it again, you know?

If he liked it then he liked it, I don't even care about that.  The point is, he loved a game many other people hated, and I bet just about everyone can say the same.  That's why the qualities that makes a video-game good are entirely relative.