Immersion vs. Interaction: conflicting gamer tastes

[The Ghost of RubangB]

Kwaad said:

The Ghost of RubangB said:

For me the new method of interaction is actually what CREATES immersion. I feel more immersed in a tennis game when I'm swinging my remote than when I'm pressing a button.

 I agree 100. However when swinging your remote has no more detail/interaction in the game, than a single button press and a slight analog movement. I see no more, if not less immersion. When I would play a 'dream' tennis game, I would hold the wiimote in my hand, and have 1:1 movement.  However the way it is, I can hold the Wiimote in my mouth, and beat the hardest level computer, and any of my friends I have played with in the past.

Now how immersive is it, when the person next to you, is kicking your ass, when you are 'trying' to play tennis. and their... deep throating a wii-mote... and winning?!?!?!

Untill 1:1 comes, I will personally enjoy my dual analog sticks, with buttons. 

My skill level on Wii Sports tennis is almost off my TV.  It's all skill.  I'm never defeated, deepthroating or not.

I'd like to see you use your mouth and beat a computer at skill level 2300!