I've played a lot with the Wii U's gamepad and PS4's controller. I've used the X1 from my friend's house but that is just for navigating X1 on Vevo, and other TV channels together with their Kinect.
I don't have any favorites between PS4 and Wii U controllers. And couldn't say about X1 as it was just a short-lived experience.
So it is a dead heat for me between PS4 and Wii U controllers.








