Biggest city in a game?

[AG80]

SvennoJ said:

AG80 said:

 

That map of Los Santos is from GTA: SA, not GTA V. GTA V's Los Santos is WAY bigger, though I'm not sure its biger than LA in LA Noire.

What about LC in GTA IV or Rome in AC: B?

You're right, I was just playing GTA 5 and that's a lot bigger, still not as big as LA Noire though.
Here's a correct comparison


Looks like GTA 5 exceeds it in total area, yet LA Noire is all city

I don't agree with your accuracy of scaling these images. For one thing I'm sure that LC in GTA IV is a lot bigger than LS in GTA: SA, not just a little big bigger. And then you have Alderney also in GTA IV's map. I can also prove it here - you can clearly see the roads marked on GTA: SA while they are barely visible in GTA IV's map which suggests that GTA IV's map is zoomed out compared to GTA: SA.