I have played both versions of GTAIV and the best version is...

[Reasonable]

rocketpig said:

Reasonable said:
Please let's no go down this route - its maddness.

The general opinion of the gaming reviewers is that the PS3 looks a little better. That's not going to change.

At home everyone has different TVs, lighting conditions in their rooms, etc. A personal opinion on this is near enough useless I'm afraid (sorry if that sounds harsh).

Also its certain that everytime someone posts '360 graphics are slightly better' there's going to be a matching 'no PS3 graphics are better'.

Let's avoid getting into a pantomine 'yes it is, no it isn't' routine people.

While I completely agree that this argument is tired and useless, realize that "professional" reviewers face the same circumstances. Most magazines have more than one person reviewing the game and it's likely that each person is playing on a separate television. Probably in a different room. Maybe not even at the same time...

All in all, this is stupid. They're both close enough where it doesn't matter. The game has enough other flaws to gripe about, we don't need to start counting bushes while you're speeding through Chase Island (or whatever the hell it's called).

Totally agree - my meaning on mentioning the reviews is that the reviews (right or wrong) are written and they're not going to change based on anything posted on these or any other forums.