So I just played TLOU for the first time..

[Eddie_Raja]

BraLoD said:

Eddie_Raja said:

I adore Rockstar's games, and imo RDR is the best game they have ever made to this day.  Objectively speaking I would probably put COD4 or RDR as second place.

-RDR because of its seamlessly open world MP

-COD4 because let's face it - it was the first good modern shooter.  Every single god damn game copied it.  It was soooo good, and it is sad lightning didn't strike twice at Infinity Ward (imo).

Even without the MP, the SP experiece in RDR is short of none bar TLoU in last gen.

I loved hunting and treasure hunting as well, the story  was also good, great ending, some really amazing immersion.

Even the DLC was amazing. Undead Nightmare was a blast.

I seriously though it would be the GOTG, until TLoU came.

Undead Nightmare is the gold standard in SP expansion packs.  $10 essentially got you a full game.