@ Starcraft
Your argument is okay, but bringing up Surfer Girl makes the whole thing fall apart.
Take here out of your argument, and you have a compelling, if not tired, argument, that you've been using for months now, but much more solid than a "surfer girl" rumor.
I don't wanna bring SG into this, but she's about as believable as a crack addict looking for his/her next fix... They'll tell you anything.