I believe we all have some of our favorite games that didn't score that well on Metacritic.
Mine would happen to be: Mystical Ninja 64
Easily the most 'anime' game on the N64, and it made some reviewers uncomfortable. I for one found it timelessly charming! Nothing else like it that entire gen.
It has a metascore of 68
The other could be Dante's Inferno on the 360. Totally scratched my GoW itch when I only had a 360. Metascore: 73
I predict NX launches in 2017 - not 2016







