| MoHasanie said: HollyGamer, you must realize that both Sunni Islam and Shia Islam both come from the same religion and both are Islam. The only difference between them is the disagreement on who succeeded the prophet. It is such a small difference, yet some people (extremists on both sides) make such a big deal about it. If you won't accept that Shia is Islam, then you're no better than Wahabbi extremists like ISIS. |
My friend you need to look and read again my post here what is the difference between the basic foundation of islamic teaching and Shia imamiyah (some shia is still on the right path but the one who rulled Iran and powerful are far from islamic teaching). When you mention the war to claim the first caliphate and who is the one who succeding the prophet already been settled a long time ago, even at that time the follower or the people that support Ali RA peace be upon him, didn't have any difference from the way Sunni pray, it was only the " politic problem ". It's fine and all.
What is the problem now actually started after the dead of Ali RA The leader who succeding Ali were started to not accepting all the Prophet Muhammad companion. Islam teach all the follower to follow all the companion especially 4 person, (Ali, Utman, Abu bakar, and Umar) including all 8 Muhammad wife, including Aisya, fatima and the rest (i forget the rest ). In Shia Imamiyah teaching especially on their hadith made by their Imam they condemn all the prophet companion and wife, except Ali RA and fatima.
Ali it self never claim that he is the one that need to be the khalifa nor to hate all the companion and all Muhammad wife. from there they starting to not accept all the right hadist "shahih hadist and lead to the bid'ah ( inovation in their teaching) that far from Muhammad teaching.
All my refference are from the history it self even you can find on shia hadith how their hadith contradicting each other. because their hadit was made by their imam, which is not the closest person to Muhammad (even some occasion their imam claim they even better the Muhammad it self LOl) .
and also wahabist is not ISIS, isis is khawarij ( some follower who overdone on how the way they pray to Allah), Wahabist is a movement that already extinct and their gola is to downplay any other teaching againts King Saud ( The saudi kingdom). Like i said the wahabist is just word trowed radomly by people who dont know anything.
