By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Johnw1104 said:
sc94597 said:

This is because of egalitarian movements actually. Because colleges have affirmative action policies, ethnic groups are competing with themselves rather than for slots with other races and that means higher test scores required for over represented groups vs. underrepresented groups. So in the eyes of governments and colleges this is equal. I view it as unequal treatment to compensate for inequalities from cultural predispositions, and that is unethical in my opinion and fuels future conflict amongst ethnic groups. Everyone should be treated as individuals first and foremost, with only a minor consideration of background.

I understand the mechanisms and reasoning that lead to this, I just think it's utter nonsense. You're supposed to compete against your fellow members of the human race, not some ill-defined "ethnicity" that you're assigned to.

They outwork the other "races" academically and score high when tested for their efforts... that's precisely how it should be, and you ought not be punished for over achieving.


I agree, but the special interest groups for Hispanic and African-Americans realize that if they try to fix this problem then they would no longer have special priveleges for the ethnic group that they represent, so such a struggle would likely split progressives and liberals across lines. For that reason I think it is unlikely that it will happen anytime soon. Asian Americans will not get this fixed because their interest groups aren't as powerful as those of underrepresented minorities, and politicians wouldn't want to divide their constiencies.