Highest Acclaimed Game By Year on Metacritic

[HomokHarcos]

Airaku said:

HomokHarcos said:

2011 - The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim (96)

I just want to point out that in 2011 Batman Arkham City was actually ranked higher than Elder Scrolls V. Arkham city was rated 0.84% higher by Game Rankings which is a site I much prefer. Metacritic is more flashy but Game Rankings seems to often be better at gathering more reviews, but for some  games Metracritic is better at doing so. That being said on Metracritic Arkham City still has a 0.2% higher user rating which regardless, would top it higher than Skyrim.

For the tiebreaker, I used the game that had more reviews.