Why GTA4 blows OoT our of the water.

[DragonLord]

Oyvoyvoyv said

Main problem here; quality is subjective
Some people find it a must-have for the game to be a revolution, some think otherwise.

And a fun fact: OoT for VC recieved the same score as GTA IV did for X360/Ps3 on IGN.

I agree completely.

Hell, if we want to argue quality and "fun" factor, I'll be honest, Rock Band is the most fun, addicting, game I've ever played.  And I've been gaming since the Atari.  Every console.

The "most fun" game I've ever played is Rock Band.  Does "fun" make it the best game ever?  Does "fun" mean I should give it a 10.0.  Nope.

You can't judge and compare an action game, an FPS, and a JRPG on the same standards.  The genres and what each accomplishes and who they appeal to is completely  different. 

A Nintendo DS game that has a 9.0 can't really be compared in THE SAME WAY to a 360 game that gets a 9.0.  It's two different animals.

It's comparing a Mouse to a Gorilla....not a German Shepard to a Husky.

It doesn't mean one is better than another, it just means they are too damn different to genuinely compare and say one is the "best."