I enjoyed Dragon Age 2 quite a bit.
I thought FF 13 was pretty good and I liked Lightning a lot more than Cloud.
I think Mario is embarrassingly bad as a character.
The auto-platforming in Uncharted 2 bored me so much that I stopped playing.
The QTEs in Tomb Raider pissed me off so much that I uninstalled on the spot.
Xenogears wasn't very good.