Star, are we on the same page or something...? I had this sort of idea of a thread for some time now, but never made it. I feel like we got some of the same ideas : P
Anyways, I`d go with Quest 64. It is often said to be one of the worst RPGs out there, but I enjoyed it a lot as a kid. Perhaps if I played it now, I wouldn`t feel the same, but I liked it as a kid. I`d say also Tales of Symphonia: Dawn of the New World. A lot of people say it`s one of the worst Tales games, but I like it.
So yeah, that`s what I got so far...
Dance my pretties!
The Official Art Thread - The Official Manga Thread - The Official Starbound Thread