I would like to thank MS for GTA4

[ToastyJaguar]

Loud_Hot_White_Box said:

starcraft said:

 

With madden the issue was that the PS3 version had half the framerate of the 360 version, which was significant.

But then there are things like RSV2 where the difference is neglibible. I've never gone around saying that tiny differences were significant. But the Sony fanboys were all over it when IGN gave CoD4 a .1 higher score on the PS3.

The thing is, all scores are relative. Thats why a game that got 10 ten years ago might get a 2 these days on graphical grounds alone. If GTAIV PS3 is the current pinacle of sandbox gaming, then by definition the Xbox version cannot get the same score if there is any discernible difference.

 

False. As I said earlier, IGN says that scores of 10 can hide flaws under features great enough to warrant a score of ten. Two different versions can have different kinds or amounts of flaws, as is the case here. The 360 version seems amazing, warranting a 10, but the PS3 version looks and loads better. Those are discernible differences.

 If the PS3 version looked loads better, then surely they would have given the 360 version less than a 10.