Is a Linear Game a Bad Game?

[Damian.W]

Depends on how the linearity is handled.
Bioshock infinite had tons of abilities, weapons, and a fantastic story that carried the corridor shooting style.

Compared to Order 1886, where the gameplay remained solid, but otherwise repetitive and short.

And further compared to something like Ride To Hell, with a terrible combat system, bland story, and atrocious visuals.