Flop or Not: PS3 Edition!

[fastyxx]

tombi123 said:
I don't know why people are saying PS3 owners are the wrong audience for LBP. R&C has sold over 1M copies, there will be a bigger user base when LBP comes out, it will be more heavily advertised then R&C. It should sell over 1M. How much do you need to sell to not be called a flop?

Haze: 800K - 1.2M. Not a huge success, but not a flop either. Average/good.

MGS4: 5 - 6M. A huge success. Hit.

LBP: 1M+. Could be a huge hit with long legs, but it is hard to say. Hit.

Killzone 2: 1.8 - 2.5M. Hit.

Resistance 2: 2.4 - 3.2M. Amazing online will make this stand out from the crowd. Hit.

GTA4: 7.5 - 8.5M What can I say. Hit.

I don't think there's any way MGS4 hits 6 million.  That's really optimistic.  If the top-selling games are only near 3 million now?  And that's with some of them being pack-ins?   There has been no sign that any game is capable of 6 million right now - even GTA4 though we are all willing to say that will move a lot lifetime.

 MGS4 at 3 million is a huge success for that game at this time.