By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
hsrob said:

Clarkson should NOT have hit the producer, plain and simple, but I do think BBC had the opportunity to be a bit smarter about how they handled this situation, particularly since Oisin Tymon did not report the incident and was seemingly interested in working it out. After all he has as much or more to lose than Clarkson here.

It's absolutely the BBC's role to protect its staff, but personally I think the BBC could have left the decision with Oisin to determine whether he felt the incident should be classified as a fight or an assault, and then proceeded accordingly. A fight at work, although not preferable, is not the end of the world and happens in workplaces around the world every day without people losing their jobs.


This would have to happen behind close doors. If Oisin was vocally responsible for Clarkson getting fired that would make his life a living hell, he's already getting death threats for simply being the victim.