By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close
Esiar said:
ZombieJesus said:

1. Time will tell.

2. Every cogent description of god possesses the following form:

Spaceless, timeless, immaterial, coupled with some maximal qualities (omni-). By this very definition, objective evidence is impossible since we live in a Universe with space, time, and material. This entity clearly cannot exist here.

That is illogical to say. God could clearly manifest himself here (and he has) since he is omnipotent, and he could make the physcial world give objective evidence of himself (which he has).

No...by this definition as cited above god is inscrutable from "nothing" since it is entirely described by the absence of properties. For example, immaterial is just to say that it lacks the property of material.

You say he could provide objective evidence, yet you fail to recognize the ridiculous and asinine argument this is.

Since this entity is not measurable, viewable, or documentable in any way, there is simply no way of confirming that "God causes X". 

All that is possible is that we observe event X. To our observations, it would appear to function entirely of its own volition in the same way that a hollywood ghost can slap a cup off the table and the haunted victim has no idea what happened.

There is no bridge from *god* to causing event X in the Universe. It's entirely untenable.