By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Don't know how metacritic works exactly but one idea is to allow (unless they're already doing this) people (with accounts and they should pass some sort of qualifying criteria to be allowed to up/downvote) should be allowed to critique critics (via critic reviews plus down/upvoting for reliability) and if a critic gets too many negative overall scores, then they should be removed from the critic pool they use to determine critic score. Should help to keep the sites honest.