well i havent played them, (i own Xillia but im currently playing other games in my backlog and i will get to it eventually) that being said i thought Xillia was quite popular and probably the best selling tales game so far, not so sure about the reviews that it got since i never pay attention to them when it comes to japanesse games, since most reviewers dont even seem to get what makes this type of games fun.
anyway i think the games are quite popular amongs the fans, but it does seems like a lot of people just think that Vesperia is probably the best, which pisses me off beyond everything... and the reason why is because the game already has a PS3 version with extra content and even a new cool character but it hasnt been localized and im sure the reason to that must be some weird contract that they signed with Microsoft... like seriously i see no other reason why they wouldnt bring that game to the west when they already remastered and localizaed Tales of Symphonia and every single other "Tales of" game of the 7th gen has gotten to the PS3...
