DS4; Excellent, best Dualshock by far, and even includes a subtle touchpad that gets it right. Love how comfy it feels in my hands.
XB1: Feels good. Analog sticks are a bit wonky though.
Wii U GamePad: Nice and light, although the battery is terrible, digital input triggers, and a lot of the time when games don't utilize the screen well, you just have a mirror of the TV and that can get annoying.
Wii U Pro: Haven't been able to try this one yet. I know it has the best battery of all and also has digital triggers.
To conclude: PS4>WiiU Pro>XB1>WiiU Pad







